A few months ago, I was with a friend of mine who hauls from
Chicago. B is awesome with a wicked sense of humor. I like to tell people she
was raised in the wild by teamsters, and it isn’t that far off from reality.
Regardless, we’re talking about Chicago’s reign as the murder capital of the
US, and she looks at me and asks if I know what the police are doing. I try to
know what the police are doing in the areas I am, call it self-preservation,
but I have no idea what they are doing in Chi-town.
B: Well, Rahm has ordered 300 desk cops into the streets to
patrol.
K: That doesn’t sound good.
B: Rahm’s job creation program. One way to get unemployment
down is to have 300 cops killed and replace them.
So yeah, this is paraphrased and a pretty dark joke. But the
point remains, Rahm, while I’m still oddly attracted to him, isn’t our friend.
He isn’t the friend of labor, the police, education, or children.
Which brings me to the point of this post, which is school
closings in Chicago; Al
Jazeera had an article. This is about saving money at the expense of
low-income students of color. This is the story of our lives. The sequester,
rolling police forces in low-income districts into one (Cleveland), lack of
funds for homeless individuals and families (DC), etc.
But let’s talk about Chicago before I launch into a full on
#IHateEverything rant. Chicago will be closing more than 50 public schools,
most of them in poor and minority neighborhoods. Rahm claims the school
closings are rough, but they are necessary to deal with the $1 billion dollar
deficit. He asserts the closings are necessary to provide students with better
education. The Chicago Sun-Times says
that one-third of the students will be sent to better performing school. The
Chicago Teachers’ Union pointing out the locations of these schools claims the
school closings are racist and classist. Yes, tell me more.
Chicago isn’t alone in this plan to close schools. Philly, Detroit,
Newark, and DC have all announced similar plans. Naturally, Pew has done a
study on this, and they found the school closings will save school districts
less than predicted. Some of the finding include: Milwaukee expected to save
$10 million a year, and found they are saving $6.5 million a year; DC expected
to save $23 million, but actually saved $17 million; and Kansas City achieved substantial
savings by laid off 700 people.
Rahm of course has claimed the students will perform better
in different schools, but research (and you know how I love research) suggests
different. The University of Chicago focused on schools closing between 2001
and 2006 and found that six percent of displaced students ended up in
high-performing schools. 42 percent of students continued to attend schools with
“very low” achievement levels. A year later, reading and math abilities weren’t
better or worse. Of course the students who did attended better-performing
schools had to travel 6km to get there which risks the safety of students who
have to travel through rival gang territories. Yep, that’s a thing.
I listen to a podcast where one of the hosts discussed her
friend a teacher was losing her job, and the teacher isn’t concerned about
finding another one, but instead worried about her students having to walk
through various gang territories to get to their new school. Digest that. That
feeling in your stomach causing you feel like you’re about to be sick, that’s
rage.
Below are a few photos from the student led protests in
opposition to the school closings from Occupied
Chicago Tribune.