So you guys remember my favorite moment of President George
W. Bush’s presidency? It was when the dude threw a show at him. I know violence
is never the answer, but no one was hurt; it was funny, and the dude had a
point to make to a man who prided himself on not needing facts.
I bring this up because Medea Benjamin, of Code Pink, heckled President Obama. Obama gives his pro-militarization propaganda
counterterrorism speech on Thursday afternoon and all of a sudden a hysterical
woman starts shouting, ain’t that always the way?
Obama began speaking about closing Gitmo and referenced being
limited by Congress, and Benjamin interrupted with: “Excuse me, President
Obama, you are commander in chief…it’s you, sir.” She continued to mention the
hunger strikes at Gtimo while President Obama continued to speak.
She continued to interrupt him as he spoke, and he stated
that she has free speech, but so does he, and then said, “I’m willing to cut
the young lady who interrupted me some slack because it’s worth being
passionate about.” (Nothing patronizing about that comment at all, sir.)
Benjamin was escorted out of the speech after she shouted
about Anwar al-Awlaki’s 16-year-old son (and US citizen) who was killed by
drone strikes. Benjamin is a regular at national security speeches and
hearings, but this time the White House seemed unaware she was present. Someone
noted that Benjamin was wearing a press pass like the reporters with her given
name “Susan Benjamin” written on it.
I didn’t actually watch the speech live, and I’m writing
this before I get to see all of it because I think we need to address a few
issues. What caught my attention is my Twitter feed blowing up when some of my
favor feminists on each side and not a crazy Republican to be found…they come.
But a few feminists whose work I admire were going back and forth on Benjamin’s
tactics (Code Pink has some controversial tactics) and respect for the office
of the presidency, though I’m thinking this has more to do with the man in the
office than the office. As previously mentioned, the shoe throwing incident
with GW didn’t seem to generate this kind of reaction from pseudo-liberals like
Benjamin’s interruption did (though I’m sure it did on the right). The
right-wing nut jobs also got in on the party with the whole office of the
presidency “bow down and kiss the ring” talk.
Below is the West Wing’s
Jed Bartlet’s take down of a hateful talk radio show host. At the end of his
take down, he takes her to task for not standing when he is because that is
what you do and decorum states (doesn’t hurt arms guards are present), but note
the setting. They are at a party not a press conference, not a speech, not a
place when the President is actually doing something and not being a figure
head. Enjoy Jed.
I wanted to show this because there are differences between
the disrespect the talk radio person shows and what Benjamin does. Benjamin is an author
(and perhaps even falls under journalist for her books, but I’m not sure what
the classifications are for press). President
Obama was giving a speech and Benjamin spoke truth to power. That is how the
job is done. President Obama needs a thick skin, and activists on behalf of
the people have to demand answers wherever the opportunity presents itself. This is Amy Goodman type shit, which is something we should demand more of from journalists.
Additionally, I can’t help but notice the very gendered
language being used to describe Benjamin. Perhaps I’m being overly sensitive as
the womenfolk are want to do, but discussions around rudeness and manners have
a different connotations for women and men, particularly in the public space.
So I ask you was the man who threw a shoe at GW’s ever called rude? I don’t
recall that. I don’t recall anyone complaining about Rahm Emanuel’s manners
either, and he sent people dead fish. Or any of the defacto Occupy leaders (I
know a leaderless movement, but the mens seem to get more talking time). Just
saying. The manners discussion only seems to be drug out when uppity womenfolk
step out of line. So complain she disrespected the office, but I don’t agree.
Complain she disrupted a press event, and I’ll say that was the point. But tell
me she is rude, and I have to roll my eyes. Because even if she was rude, who
the fuck cares this is politics (Benjamin was a Green Party Senate candidate at
one point), and everyone is rude or have we already forgotten Joe Biden’s
epicness in his debate with Paul Ryan? Of course, thems the menfolk again,
which appears to make being rude ok, entertaining, and what you can expect when
you’re outmatched.
Perhaps that is the real problem, was President Obama outmatched?
Could he not provide responses to Benjamin? Blaming Congress for Gitmo is weak,
and the White House has said in the past killing a US child is the cost of that
child having a bad father. Did President Obama not want to say that in front of
the press? I think I’m giving everyone too much credit. President Obama has
joined the ranks of those who came before him, and no longer knows how to be
treated as a mere mortal. We saw it in the Presidential debates as well.
Below you’ll find the video of Benjamin being escorted out
and a tweet from Allison Kilkenny of a photo of Benjamin being removed.