I’m seriously digging how much trouble the new Pope is causing. I’m
still not in, he’s anti-gay (thought I read he might be changing his tune on
equality in the law, but not in faith), and women aren’t high on his list of making things awesome, but then
he goes and washes the feet of the poor, drops mic.
This doesn’t sound like radical stuff, but it is. I mean the Vatican has
been targeting religious women in the States for their involvement with the
poor (and property rights…long story), and now, Pope Francis is pulling some
Dorothy Day/Catholic Worker hospitality shit right there in Rome for anyone to
see.It is almost like he doesn't know the rules.
On Holy Thursday, Pope Francis washed
the feet of 12 people (as is tradition, though usually priests are chosen
to represent the apostles, and Francis has a history of people the poor
instead) including, women, men, Christians, Muslims, and those with tattoos. I
know! Can
you feel the scandal?
Pope Francis said, “This is a symbol, it is a sign. Washing your feet
means I am at your service. Help one another. This is what Jesus teaches us.
This is what I do. And I do it with my heart. I do this with my heart because
it is my duty. As a priest and bishop, I must be at your service.”
That is straight Jesuit teaching; be a man and woman for others. Francis’ commitment to the poor was cool when he was still in Buenos
Aires, but now he’s setting a bad example by reaching out to the marginalized
groups like women and poor people. Of course, this sent the reactionary
Catholics into a tizzy, Canon lawyer Edward Peters, an advisor to the Holy See’s
top court, said, “By disregarding his own law in this matter, Francis violates,
of course, no divine directive. What he does do, I fear, is set a questionable
example.”
Obviously, Pope Francis by touch a woman’s feet is signaling the
ordination of women as priests, and he’ll perform the first Catholic gay
wedding on Eastern Sunday. This will usher in a new era of Catholic Progress
and mandate social justice reforms internationally. Oh wait. None of that is
going to happen. After all, in 2011, then-Cardinal Bergoglio wrote in his book On Heaven and Earth, that the priesthood
is reserved for men “because Jesus was a man.” This is my favorite kind of logic…you
know the kind that makes no since. For me, I just scream SCIENCE at the top of
my lungs to shut people up when I don’t want to engage with them. It is usually
accompanied by me running away. There is also a hand motion, but I don’t want
to get into too much detail and ruin it for those of you who know me.
My sophomore year of undergrad at a Jesuit University I had this very
conversation with a seminarian (priest in training). We’ll call him A (because
I can’t remember his name) and a little set up. There were three women in our
history course on Catholicism in modern US history and none of us were
Catholic. Most of the class was made up of seminarians. I sat behind one of them,
when our very progressive priest instructor asked if women should be ordained.
Me: “Yes, they should. My aunt is a Roman Catholic nun and would be an
excellent priest.”
A: [turns around in seat to address me] "Absolutely not. Why does she want
to be a priest? To be in front? There are roles for women behind the scenes,
and if she wants to be out front then she isn’t doing it for the right reasons.”
Me: “So why do you want to be a priest? Because there are roles for men
behind the scenes too like monks.”
Sweet, sweet silence.
Honestly, I think A’s point was more revealing about his intentions as a
priest than my aunt’s motivation, which is slightly rooted in feminism and the
quest for equality and representation within her faith. At the end of the day
what this is really about is women being seen as people by the Catholic Church,
and this is the most movement we’ve seen on that front since they said nuns
didn’t have to wear the habit. So I’ll take what we can get. The bar is pretty
low after all. Maybe, just maybe women will be seen as more than their
reproductive capacities soon. Probably not though.
And now Pope Francis is giving all the progressives in the Catholic faith something to hope for, which they haven't had since before Pope John Paul II passed, actually before he got real sick.